7 Causes of Poor Employee Performance - And How to Address Them

It’s every manager’s least favorite part of the job: someone on your team isn’t performing up to expectations, and it’s time to do something about it.

But before you decide how to address a performance problem, it’s important to diagnose the root cause.

In my experience, performance is the confluence of ability and motivation. An employee needs to have the ability to perform the task as well as the motivation to do so. Figuring out which is the cause of the performance problem can help you decide how to address it.

Lack of ability

The first four causes stem from a lack of ability:

1. Resources
   If your employee is lacking the time, money, personnel, or supplies to complete a task, he won’t be able to complete it, no matter how much he wants to. This is probably the easiest root cause to address, but you should also tell the employee that he should have come to you with his problem sooner instead of trying to make it work without the proper resources.
2. Obstacles
   Obstacles might include getting a decision from clients or higher-ups, problems collaborating with another department, or other obstacles outside the employee’s control. As the manager, hopefully you can step in and help her tackle or find a way around the obstacle to get the job done.
3. Skills
   Sometimes a performance problem is a simple lack of skills. Perhaps the employee was promoted before he was ready, or a new set of job duties has been assigned. Hopefully some extra training or mentoring can solve this performance problem.
4. Expectations
   If no clear parameters or expectations for a project have been set, or if the employee has misunderstood them, this can be a major cause of poor performance. Go over project goals and deliverables again and see if you can help clear up any confusion or miscommunication.

Lack of Motivation:

The second set of causes for poor performance are more personal and emotional to the employee and are based in a lack of motivation:

1. No carrots
   Are employees praised or rewarded for good work? Some employees may begin to slack off if they perceive that their hard work goes unrecognised. For some people, having their good work recognised is vitally important to their work satisfaction, and their performance may improve just from past good works being recognized.
2. No sticks
   The opposite problem to having no carrots is having no sticks. If there are no penalties for poor performance, some employees may feel they can “get away with” turning work in late or shoddily done. Don’t just start handing down punishments suddenly, however; take the time to review or design a step-by-step series of consequences for poor performance and announce them to the entire team before implementing. The first step can be as simple as talking about the problem, with consequences increasing from there.
3. Burnout
   If an employee seems bored or burned out, it’s the manager’s job to try to help reenergize him. Being burned out is not a free pass for doing sub-par work, but it is a red flag to a good manager that the employee’s talents may be underutilized. A quick note: poor performance can also be a passive-aggressive way for an employee to try to redress what she sees as wrong, so be aware if she seems to harbor any anger or resentment as well.

As you can see, one size does not fit all when it comes to handling performance problems. Handing down a punishment for someone who lacks the proper resources or doesn’t have the necessary skills isn’t the right approach; nor is prescribing additional training for someone who really needs praise. Identifying the root cause of the performance problem is key before you can find the right solution.

Are you a manager who has had to deal with performance problems in the past? How did you diagnose the problem to find the proper solution? I’d love for you to share your experiences in the comments below.

----------------

Thank you for reading my post. I regularly write about performance management
as well as the mega-trend that is Big Data for LinkedIn and Forbes. If you would like to read my regular posts then please click 'Follow' and feel free to also connect via Twitter, Facebook and The Advanced Performance Institute. When I am not writing then I help companies put in place performance management approaches that work. My latest book is Key Performance Indicators For Dummies.

To celebrate the launch of this book, Rocket Software is sponsoring a book launch and you are invited. Why don’t you join us on April 23rd in London, I would love to meet you and you get a chance to network over a glass of champagne and also receive a complementary signed copy of my book. For more information and to register, go here: http://info.rocketsoftware.com/Bernard-Marr-Book-Event-registration.html

Finally, here are some other recent posts I have written on the topic:

• Meet 7 Brand New Big Data Billionaires
• How the FBI Manages Performance
• How To Set Performance Targets That Work
• The Seven Secrets of Top Performers
• The Top 5 Performance Management Tools: Good News And Cautionary Tales
• The 25 KPIs Every Manager Needs to Know
• Wrong KPIs? Why Questions Are The Answer!

Photo: Shutterstock.com